Start a Claim Login

Real cases.
Plain English.

14
Cases covered
$3.8M+
Total damages across cases
Filter by
Psychiatric injury Workplace injury Co-worker Assault PTSD

$585,000 After Warning Signs Went Unheeded

Colwell v Top Cut Foods Pty Ltd [2018] QDC 119

Colwell v Top Cut Foods Pty Ltd [2018] QDC 119 A butcher was punched repeatedly by a co-worker with a known history of violence, after weeks of tension both men had raised with their supervisor. The District Court found the employer should have separated them and awarded $584,995.

$584,995
Total awarded, after WorkCover refund
Read breakdown
Psychiatric injury Workplace injury Client Violence Foreseeability

$1.5 Million After an Employer Ignored the Warning Signs

Brisbane Youth Service Inc v Beven [2017] QCA 211

Brisbane Youth Service Inc v Beven [2017] QCA 211 A family support worker developed a serious psychiatric injury after a client with a known history of sexualised and threatening behaviour towards staff assaulted her at a meeting. The Supreme Court awarded her $1,508,639, finding her employer should have stopped providing services to the client. The Court of Appeal upheld the decision 2 to 1.

$1,508,639
Awarded at trial, upheld on appeal
Read breakdown
Public liability Slip & Fall Occupier's Liability Wet Steps

$650,000 for a Slip on Wet, Unlit Steps

Silwood v Chandler [2016] QCA 273

Silwood v Chandler [2016] QCA 273 A mother slipped on her former partner's front steps at night after he had hosed the area that afternoon and left it wet, with the outside light off. She put her arm through a glass door. The Supreme Court awarded her the agreed $650,000, and the Court of Appeal upheld the decision.

$650,000
Awarded at trial, upheld on appeal
Read breakdown
Road accident Future Economic Loss Minor Injury

$40,000 Cut to $15,000, But Not to Zero

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v McCarthy [2012] QCA 312

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v McCarthy [2012] QCA 312 A young woman's foot was run over by a car on a Brisbane footpath, leaving a 1% permanent impairment. The District Court awarded $40,000 for future economic loss. On Allianz's appeal, the Court of Appeal cut that to $15,000, but still recognised a modest chance of lost earnings, giving a final judgment of $32,200.

$32,200
Final judgment after appeal
Read breakdown
Vicarious liability Security Guards Vicarious Liability

Security Company Liable for Its Guards' Assault

Sprod v Public Relations Oriented Security Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 319

Sprod v Public Relations Oriented Security Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 319 Security guards removed a drunk patron from a St Marys pizza shop, then assaulted him in a nearby laneway, leaving him with permanent brain damage. The trial judge found the guards acted for their own reasons. The NSW Court of Appeal disagreed, holding their employer vicariously liable and sending the case back for damages to be assessed.

Liability won
Damages sent back to the Supreme Court to assess
Read breakdown
Contributory negligence Road accident Bruce Highway Contributory Negligence

$800,000 in Damages, Cut in Half

Habig v McCrae [2013] QSC 335

Habig v McCrae [2013] QSC 335 A broken-down, unlit van was partly blocking the Bruce Highway at 10pm when a bread truck crashed into it. The truck driver was negligent, but so was the injured passenger, who stayed near the van without warning traffic or moving to safety. The court split responsibility 50/50 and halved $800,000 in damages to $400,000.

$400,000
Received after 50% reduction
Read breakdown
Slip & Fall Causation High Court

$580,299 Won, Lost, Then Won Back

Strong v Woolworths Ltd [2012] HCA 5

Strong v Woolworths Ltd [2012] HCA 5 Ms Strong, who used crutches, slipped on a chip in a sidewalk sale area controlled by Big W at about 12.30pm. The area hadn't been inspected since 8am. She won $580,299 at trial, lost in the NSW Court of Appeal on causation, then won in the High Court, which found the chip had more likely than not been there long enough to be found and removed.

$580,299
Trial judgment, reinstated by the High Court
Read breakdown
Causation Workplace injury Criminal Act Causation

Almost $3 Million Awarded, Then Overturned

Coca-Cola Amatil (NSW) Pty Ltd v Pareezer [2006] NSWCA 45

Coca-Cola Amatil (NSW) Pty Ltd v Pareezer [2006] NSWCA 45 A vending machine filler contracted to Coca-Cola Amatil was shot five times in a 1997 robbery at Werrington TAFE, where he had been attacked before. The NSW Supreme Court awarded about $2.89 million. The Court of Appeal overturned it because he couldn't show that any reasonable precaution would have stopped the gunman.

$2.89M
Awarded at trial, overturned on appeal
Read breakdown
Road accident Pedestrian No Contributory Negligence

Nearly $1 Million After Being Hit by a Car

Eden v Jamieson [2023] QSC 240

Eden v Jamieson [2023] QSC 240 An electrician walking on the edge of a dark, straight road in Dysart was struck from behind by a car. The Supreme Court found the driver should have seen him from about 80 metres away and was negligent. No contributory negligence was found, even though he was walking on the road, and damages were assessed at $987,654.99.

$987,655
Total damages awarded
Read breakdown
Workplace Bullying Psychiatric Injury Employer Policy

$237,770 for a Bullying Complaint Ignored

Keegan v Sussan Corporation (Aust.) Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 64

Keegan v Sussan Corporation (Aust.) Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 64 A respected assistant store manager in Cairns returned from maternity leave to a new manager who bullied her. When she called her business manager in tears, Sussan ignored its own bullying policy and left her to sort it out herself. The Supreme Court found that response breached Sussan's duty of care and awarded her $237,770 after the WorkCover refund.

$237,770
Judgment after WorkCover refund
Read breakdown
Psychiatric injury Overwork Performance Management

Over $1 Million After Being Overworked and Blamed

Ackers v Cairns Regional Council [2021] QSC 342

Ackers v Cairns Regional Council [2021] QSC 342 A payroll supervisor worked about 12 extra hours a week for 14 weeks during a staffing crisis, then had virtually every mistake blamed on him personally. The Supreme Court found Council caused his major depressive illness by putting him on a performance plan without following its own procedures, and gave judgment for $1,099,132.69.

$1,099,132
Judgment after WorkCover refund
Read breakdown
Psychiatric injury Supervisor Misconduct Causation

From $100 at Trial to $364,008 on Appeal

Wolters v The University of the Sunshine Coast [2013] QCA 228

Wolters v The University of the Sunshine Coast [2013] QCA 228 A security officer developed a psychiatric injury after a senior manager publicly yelled at her and wrongly accused her of abandoning her duties. The university had failed to investigate or properly counsel him after an earlier incident. She lost on causation at trial, receiving only $100 nominal damages, but the Court of Appeal found in her favour and ordered damages of $364,008.06.

$364,008
Ordered on appeal
Read breakdown
Workplace injury Duty of Care PTSD

$239,000 After a Workplace Sexual Assault

Gilmour v Blue Care [2024] QDC 189

Gilmour v Blue Care [2024] QDC 189 Blue Care was found to have breached its duty of care in three distinct ways after a female care worker was sexually assaulted at an Ipswich hostel. The court rejected the employer's argument that the assault was unforeseeable, and found no contributory negligence against the worker.

$239,000
Total awarded
Read breakdown
Coming soon

More cases being added

New breakdown dropping soon

Alex is working through more Queensland decisions. Follow @wiseguy_qld on TikTok to catch each breakdown as it drops.

—
Stay tuned
Follow on TikTok

Been in a similar situation?

Understanding the law is the first step. Taking action is the second. Talk to Alex for free.