Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

Almost $3 Million Awarded, Then Overturned

Coca-Cola Amatil (NSW) Pty Ltd v Pareezer [2006] NSWCA 45

A man who refilled Coca-Cola vending machines was shot five times during a robbery at a TAFE campus in western Sydney, a site where he had been attacked before. He won almost $3 million at trial. The Court of Appeal took it all away. Here's what happened and why it matters.

Showing that a business knew about a danger and didn't do enough is not the end of the case. You also have to show that the precautions it should have taken would probably have stopped your injury.

5
Times he was shot during the robbery
$2.89M
Awarded at trial, including to his family
$0
Left after the Court of Appeal overturned the win
The Case

Coca-Cola Amatil (NSW) Pty Ltd v Pareezer [2006] NSWCA 45

Mr Pareezer was contracted to Coca-Cola Amatil as a filler. His job was to drive to sites, restock Coke vending machines and collect the cash inside them. One of his sites was the TAFE campus at Werrington in western Sydney, where he had already been attacked and injured on an earlier visit.

In 1997, while servicing the machines at Werrington, he was confronted by an armed robber and shot five times, including in the head and chest. He survived with serious injuries. The man who shot him was later jailed for attempted murder.

Mr Pareezer sued Coca-Cola Amatil for negligence. This is a decision of the NSW Court of Appeal, so it doesn’t bind Queensland courts, but it is often cited and the same basic causation question applies here: would reasonable precautions probably have prevented the injury?

Read the full judgment on AustLII

What the Court Decided

At trial in the NSW Supreme Court, Justice Hulme found Coca-Cola Amatil negligent for requiring Mr Pareezer to collect money from a site it knew carried an unreasonable risk of assault and robbery. In December 2004 he was awarded about $2.89 million, with smaller amounts also awarded to his wife and son.

Coca-Cola Amatil appealed. Mr Pareezer pointed to precautions he said it should have taken, such as robbery awareness training, a second person working with him, personal alarms, and a guard to escort him. The Court of Appeal, in reasons given by Young CJ in Eq with the other judges agreeing, accepted that the law only requires the defendant’s failure to be a cause of the injury. But it found the evidence didn’t show any of those precautions would probably have prevented this robbery.

The court regarded the gunman as acting so irrationally that reasonable security measures were unlikely to have stopped him. The appeal was allowed and the award overturned. Coca-Cola Amatil then indicated it would seek repayment of about $560,000 that had already been paid to Mr Pareezer.

Why the win didn't survive the appeal

The trial judge and the Court of Appeal looked at the same robbery. They parted ways on whether better precautions would have made any difference.

1

The trial judge found the site was known to be dangerous

Justice Hulme found Coca-Cola Amatil negligent for requiring Mr Pareezer to collect money from a site it knew posed an unreasonable risk of assault and robbery, and awarded about $2.89 million.

2

The suggested precautions weren't shown to work

Training, a second worker, personal alarms and a security escort were all put forward. The Court of Appeal found no evidence that any of them would probably have prevented this particular robbery.

3

The gunman's behaviour broke the causal link

The court saw the robber as acting so irrationally that reasonable security measures were unlikely to have deterred him. That meant the company's failures could not be shown to have caused the injury.

Alex's Take
“

This is one of the harshest results you’ll read. A worker was sent back to a place where he’d already been attacked, and he was shot. The trial judge thought the company should pay. The appeal court still said no, because the case couldn’t show that doing things differently would probably have changed what happened.

That’s the hard part of claims involving criminals. A court will often accept that a business could have done more. The question is whether the extra precautions would actually have stopped this offender, on this day. If the attacker is reckless and determined enough, the answer may be no, and the claim fails on causation even where the risk was well known.

If you’ve been hurt by a third party at work, your claim needs evidence about what security would have done in practice, not just a list of things your employer could have tried. In Queensland, a work injury also usually means a WorkCover claim, which doesn’t depend on proving negligence. Get advice early so both avenues are protected.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened at work.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →