Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

Over $1 Million After Being Overworked and Blamed

Ackers v Cairns Regional Council [2021] QSC 342

A council payroll supervisor was worked into the ground during a staffing crisis, then blamed for every mistake the unit made. The Supreme Court found his employer had caused his major depressive illness.

If your employer knew you were struggling and did nothing, or worse, made things harder, this case has something to say about your rights.

$1.1M
Judgment entered for the worker
2
Distinct breaches found against the employer
14 weeks
Of sustained overwork, about 12 extra hours a week
The Case

Ackers v Cairns Regional Council [2021] QSC 342

The plaintiff was hired by Cairns Regional Council in September 2014 to overhaul and supervise a badly inefficient payroll unit that required large amounts of manual data input. His early performance reviews were very positive, despite having a longstanding mental health history.

In March 2015, three experienced payroll staff went on prolonged leave. For the next 14 weeks, the plaintiff worked around 12 extra hours per week, including two all-nighters, just to keep Council’s payroll functioning. During this time Council could see he was under enormous strain, showing visible signs of distress including uncontrollable tremors and emotionality.

Rather than address the staffing problem, Council issued a written warning following a union complaint, conducted an audit that blamed the plaintiff for virtually all of the unit’s mistakes while ignoring the obvious understaffing, and then placed him on a Performance Improvement Action Plan. By September 2015 he had suffered a major depressive illness and ceased work.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

The Supreme Court found that psychiatric injury only became reasonably foreseeable in July 2015, after the plaintiff disclosed his depression and antidepressant use to his supervisor, adding to everything Council already knew about his workload and distress. Prior to that, the extra hours and visible distress alone were not enough. Courts give employers some leeway where an employee hasn’t disclosed a mental health condition.

But once that disclosure was made, Council’s response was inadequate on two fronts. It failed to inject replacement staff to relieve the plaintiff’s load, and it pursued a formal performance management process without ever asking whether the workload and understaffing might be contributing to the performance issues it was trying to address.

The court found it was the Performance Improvement Action Plan, imposed while Council knew the plaintiff was suffering under sustained understaffing, that caused his major depressive illness. Blaming the employee for a systemic problem the employer created, without following its own procedures, was the decisive breach. The court gave judgment for the plaintiff for $1,099,132.69.

Where the court found Council went wrong

Once psychiatric injury became foreseeable in July, Council had a duty to act. It failed in two distinct ways, and the court found the second is what caused his illness.

1

Failure to properly staff the payroll unit

From July onwards, it would have been reasonable for Council to train up and inject short-term replacement staff to relieve the plaintiff's load. The prolonged understaffing was the root cause of the problem, and Council knew it. Choosing not to address it after the plaintiff's disclosure was a breach of its duty of care.

2

Failure to follow its own performance management procedures

Council's own administrative procedures required supervisors to consider whether there were factors preventing an employee from performing before moving into formal performance management. Council ignored this entirely. With full knowledge of the extraordinary stress the plaintiff was under due to prolonged understaffing, it imposed and pursued a PIAP that blamed him personally for a systemic failure it had created.

3

The performance plan caused his illness

The court found that imposing and pursuing the PIAP caused the plaintiff's major depressive illness. He has not returned to work since September 2015, and his lost past and future earnings made up the largest part of the award.

Alex's Take
“

What makes this case important is the performance management piece. Councils and large employers often reach for the PIAP when things go wrong in a unit. What this decision says is that if you do that while knowing the employee is struggling under conditions you created and haven’t fixed, you are not managing performance, you are causing harm.

The disclosure in July is the other thing worth noting. Before that, Council had some cover. After it, they had none. If you are an employee dealing with a mental health condition and your working conditions are contributing to it, telling your employer in writing matters enormously, both practically and legally.

Psychiatric injury claims are hard-fought and every case turns on its own facts. If your workload or the way you’re being managed is affecting your mental health, get advice early, while the emails, rosters and records that show what your employer knew are still easy to find.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened at work.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →