Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

$800,000 in Damages, Cut in Half

Habig v McCrae [2013] QSC 335

A young German tourist was standing near a broken-down, unlit van on the Bruce Highway at night when a bread truck crashed into it. The court found the truck driver negligent, but it also found the injured man partly responsible for what happened to him. Here's what happened and why it matters.

Being hurt by someone else's negligence doesn't guarantee full compensation. What you did, or didn't do, to keep yourself safe in the moments before an accident can reduce your payout significantly.

$800,000
Damages agreed before any reduction
50%
Reduction for contributory negligence
$400,000
Final judgment for the injured man
The Case

Habig v McCrae [2013] QSC 335

At about 10pm on 22 June 2006, a Toyota Hiace van broke down on the southbound Bruce Highway north of Pindi Pindi, near Calen in North Queensland. It came to rest angled across at least half of the southbound lane. There were no street lights, the van’s lights were off, and the night was very dark.

The plaintiff, a young German tourist travelling in the van, and his companion stayed near it. Witnesses saw them there, but they didn’t try to push the van off the road, warn oncoming traffic, or move a safe distance away.

A loaded bread truck approached on low beam. Its driver was distracted by the headlights of a 4WD parked on the other side of the road. He saw the van at the last moment, braked and swerved, but hit its rear. The plaintiff suffered a serious head injury.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

The Supreme Court found the truck driver negligent. He had taken his eyes off the road ahead to look at the parked 4WD, stayed on low beam when high beam was available, and was travelling at a speed that didn’t allow him to stop within the distance he could see. Had he kept a proper lookout, he would have seen the van in time to avoid it.

The defendants argued the plaintiff had voluntarily accepted the risk by staying near the van. The court rejected that. Being aware of an obvious risk is not the same as freely agreeing to accept it.

However, the court did find the plaintiff contributorily negligent. By staying near an unlit van partly blocking a dark highway, without warning traffic or moving away, he failed to take reasonable care for his own safety. The court found the two sides’ fault evenly balanced and reduced his agreed damages of $800,000 by 50%, giving judgment for $400,000.

Where the court placed the blame

The court found fault on both sides of the collision, then weighed each party's conduct against the other.

1

The truck driver failed to keep a proper lookout

As he approached, the driver's attention was drawn to a 4WD with its headlights on, parked on the other side of the highway. The court held that noticing one hazard doesn't justify ignoring the road ahead. A driver keeping a proper lookout would have seen the van in time.

2

He didn't adjust his driving to what he could see

On a dark, unlit highway, the driver kept his headlights on low beam and travelled at a speed the court found was likely between 85 and 95 km/h. Drivers must control their speed so they can stop or steer around anything within the range of their lights.

3

The injured man didn't protect himself

The plaintiff stayed near an unlit van that was partly blocking a dark highway. He didn't try to warn oncoming drivers or move a safe distance away. The court found this was a failure to take reasonable care for his own safety, and that his share of the blame was equal to the driver's.

Alex's Take
“

This case shows how contributory negligence works in practice. The truck driver was clearly at fault. He was looking at the wrong thing at the wrong time, and the court said so. But the injured man still lost $400,000 because of what he didn’t do in the minutes before the crash.

Notice what the court didn’t do. The insurer wanted his damages reduced to nothing. The court refused. A finding that you contributed to your own injury reduces your compensation; it doesn’t automatically wipe it out. How much it reduces it is a fight worth having, and the evidence about what you could reasonably have done in the moment matters a great deal.

If you’ve been injured and you’re worried you were partly to blame, don’t assume you have no claim. Get advice before you accept anyone else’s view of who was at fault.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →