Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

$1.5 Million After an Employer Ignored the Warning Signs

Brisbane Youth Service Inc v Beven [2017] QCA 211

A family support worker was sexually assaulted by a client during a formal meeting. Her employer knew the client had behaved in sexualised and threatening ways towards other staff, who had stopped working with her. The courts found the employer should have stopped offering services to that client. Here's what happened and why it matters.

Doing socially valuable work doesn't lower the bar on keeping your own staff safe. When an employer knows a client poses a real risk to workers, it must respond to that risk, even if the answer is to stop the service.

$1,508,639
Damages awarded, clear of the WorkCover refund
$711,596
For future loss of earnings
2 to 1
Court of Appeal majority that upheld the win
The Case

Brisbane Youth Service Inc v Beven [2017] QCA 211

Ms Beven worked as a family support worker for Brisbane Youth Service (BYS), an organisation supporting young people facing homelessness and disadvantage. In October 2010 she agreed to take on a client referred to in court as “T”, a young mother with a long history of drug use, mental illness, self-harm and sexualised behaviour.

Two earlier BYS workers had already experienced sexual advances and threatening behaviour from T, and had withdrawn from working with her at home. BYS put some safeguards in place for Ms Beven, such as phone check-ins when arriving and leaving T’s home, but she continued visiting T there regularly, about 17 times over five months.

On 13 April 2011, at a family meeting with Child Safety officers and others present, T touched Ms Beven sexually and repeated it after being told to stop. Ms Beven developed major depressive disorder and an aggravation of earlier post-traumatic stress disorder, and never returned to work.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

At trial in the Supreme Court, Justice Atkinson found the risk of assault, including sexual assault, was clearly foreseeable given what BYS knew about T. BYS’s social work was valuable, but that didn’t displace its duty to its own staff. The judge found that the regular home visits had built the relationship that gave T the opportunity to behave as she did, and that BYS should have declined to keep offering services to T and referred her elsewhere. Ms Beven was awarded $1,508,639.35, after repaying $264,394.11 to WorkCover.

BYS appealed, arguing that an assault at a formal meeting with several officials present wasn’t foreseeable, and that stopping services was too much to ask. On 22 September 2017 the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal by majority. President Sofronoff and Justice Gotterson held the risk was foreseeable and that ending services was a reasonable precaution. Justice McMurdo dissented, finding the risk in that meeting setting was slight and that withdrawing services entirely would have been an unreasonable constraint on the employer.

Why the employer was held responsible

The employer argued an assault in a formal meeting full of people couldn't have been foreseen. The trial judge and the majority of the Court of Appeal disagreed.

1

The employer knew the risk

Before Ms Beven took on the case, BYS knew T had made sexual advances towards and threatened other workers, two of whom had stepped back from working with her. A reasonable employer would have been alert to the risk of assault.

2

A formal setting didn't remove the risk

BYS argued no one could foresee an assault in a meeting full of officials. The majority disagreed, noting that assaults can happen in unlikely and public places, and that psychiatric injury commonly follows sexual assault.

3

The safeguards weren't enough

Phone check-ins and timing visits around Child Safety appointments didn't address the real problem: the ongoing relationship that gave T the opportunity to target Ms Beven. The court found BYS should have stopped providing services to T.

4

Her vulnerability didn't defeat the claim

Ms Beven had a history of earlier trauma that BYS didn't know about, which made her injury more severe. The court still held BYS liable, because the type of harm was foreseeable and she was functioning well at work beforehand.

Alex's Take
“

This case matters for anyone working in care, community services, health or youth work. Your job may involve some risk, but that doesn’t mean your employer can ignore clear warning signs about a particular person. Here, two workers before Ms Beven had already pulled back from this client. The employer knew.

It’s also a reminder that the court looks at what the employer could reasonably have done, and sometimes that’s a hard call, like ending a service. The court didn’t say every difficult client must be turned away. It said that, on these facts, continuing to send a worker to this client wasn’t reasonable.

If you’ve been hurt by a client or member of the public at work, write down what you and your colleagues had reported beforehand, and who knew. That history is often what decides whether the risk was foreseeable.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened at work.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →