Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

$40,000 Cut to $15,000, But Not to Zero

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v McCarthy [2012] QCA 312

A young woman's foot was run over by a car on a Brisbane footpath, leaving her with a 1% permanent impairment. Her insurer appealed the $40,000 she was awarded for future loss of earnings. The Court of Appeal cut it, but still awarded $15,000. Here's what happened and why it matters.

A minor injury can still affect what you earn over a working life. Courts will compensate a real chance of future loss, but only to the extent the evidence supports it.

1%
Whole person impairment from the foot injury
$15,000
Future economic loss after appeal, down from $40,000
$32,200
Final judgment, down from $59,448.67 at trial
The Case

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v McCarthy [2012] QCA 312

In March 2008, Ms McCarthy was walking along a footpath on North Quay in Brisbane. A car was stopped across the footpath, waiting to pull out into heavy traffic. As she walked in front of it, the car moved forward without warning and stopped on her right foot for 10 to 15 seconds before driving off. The driver’s insurer, Allianz, admitted liability.

Ms McCarthy was in her early twenties, an elite rower who worked full-time in an administration role at a bank while studying business, majoring in event management, part-time. She suffered a crush injury to the front of her foot and developed arthritic changes in the joint at the base of her big toe. Her permanent impairment was assessed at just 1% of the whole person.

She told the court that standing for long periods made her foot sore and that high heels made it worse, and that this could hold her back in a future career in events. In December 2011 the District Court accepted the arthritis would get worse and awarded her $59,448.67, including $40,000 for future economic loss. Allianz appealed.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

The Court of Appeal agreed the $40,000 figure couldn’t stand. Under section 55 of the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), when a court awards a lump sum for future loss of earnings that can’t be precisely calculated, it must explain the assumptions behind the figure. The trial judge’s reasons didn’t show how she arrived at $40,000, and the evidence pointed to only a modest risk of income loss.

But the majority did not wipe the award out. President McMurdo and Justice Gotterson found Ms McCarthy faced a real, though small, chance of being disadvantaged in the job market, especially in roles that involve a lot of standing, over a long working life. They substituted a modest global award of $15,000 for future economic loss, plus $1,350 for lost superannuation. The final judgment was $32,200.

Justice White dissented on this point. She would have awarded nothing for future economic loss, finding the evidence didn’t show the injury had reduced Ms McCarthy’s earning capacity in a way that was likely to cost her money. Allianz was awarded its costs of the appeal.

How the court valued a small injury

The appeal turned on one question: what is a small but permanent injury worth in lost future earnings?

1

The injury was minor but permanent

The court accepted Ms McCarthy had a 1% whole person impairment and that the arthritis in her foot would get worse over time, causing pain with prolonged standing, running and lunging.

2

The $40,000 award wasn't properly explained

The trial judge didn't set out how she reached $40,000 for future economic loss. Section 55 of the Civil Liability Act requires a court to state the assumptions it relies on, so the figure couldn't stand.

3

A small risk still deserves a modest award

The majority found that, over a long working life, there was a real if modest chance the injury would limit Ms McCarthy's job options and earnings. They replaced $40,000 with $15,000 rather than nothing.

4

The final judgment was $32,200

With future economic loss cut to $15,000 and superannuation to $1,350, the total fell from $59,448.67 to $32,200, and Ms McCarthy was ordered to pay Allianz's costs of the appeal.

Alex's Take
“

People with smaller injuries often ask me whether a claim is even worth it. This case is a useful answer. A 1% impairment is about as minor as permanent injuries get, yet the Court of Appeal still accepted that over a long working life, it carried a real chance of costing her income, and it put a dollar figure on that chance.

The case also shows the limits. The award was cut by more than half, one judge would have allowed nothing, and she had to pay the insurer’s costs of the appeal. Future economic loss isn’t awarded just because you say your injury might affect your career. You need evidence that ties your injury to the work you do or are heading towards: what the job involves, what your doctors say you can’t do, and how that could affect what you earn.

So if you’ve got what feels like a minor injury, don’t dismiss it, but don’t overreach either. Get advice on what the evidence can genuinely support before you settle.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →