Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

Security Company Liable for Its Guards' Assault

Sprod v Public Relations Oriented Security Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 319

A drunk patron was removed from a late-night pizza shop by security guards, then assaulted in a nearby laneway and left with permanent brain damage. The trial judge said the guards were acting for themselves. The Court of Appeal said their employer was responsible. Here's what happened and why it matters.

When a worker hurts you while doing their job, even in a way their employer never allowed, the employer can be liable. The question is whether the act was connected to the job or purely personal.

3-0
Court of Appeal judges who found the employer liable
20 min
Guards stayed with him calmly before the assault
4 months
In hospital, with permanent brain damage
The Case

Sprod v Public Relations Oriented Security Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 319

At about 1.30am on 22 December 2001, Mr Sprod was very drunk and abusive inside a late-night pizza shop on the Great Western Highway at St Marys, in Sydney’s west. The shop had an arrangement with a nearby club: when the owner needed help, the club’s security guards would come over. Those guards were employed by a security company, Public Relations Oriented Security Pty Ltd.

Guards came to the shop and got Mr Sprod outside. For around 20 minutes they stayed with him on the footpath further along the highway, without striking or threatening him. Two guards then took him into a dark private laneway nearby while two others kept watch, and assaulted him. He was found unconscious with a severe head injury, spent almost four months in hospital and was left with permanent brain damage. He sued the security company through a family member acting on his behalf.

This is a New South Wales decision. Vicarious liability is a common law principle applied across Australia, so the case is persuasive in Queensland, though not binding. The High Court has since restated the test in Prince Alfred College v ADC (2016), which asks whether the employee’s role gave them the occasion for the wrongful act.

Read the full judgment on AustLII

What the Court Decided

At trial in the Supreme Court, the judge accepted the guards had assaulted Mr Sprod but found the company wasn’t responsible. He rejected the claim that the company itself had been negligent in training or supervising the guards, and he found the assault was an independent act of the guards, done for their own reasons and well outside what they were employed to do.

The Court of Appeal unanimously disagreed on vicarious liability. Looking at the whole of the evidence, it found the guards’ main purpose was still to do their job: to stop Mr Sprod coming back to the shop and causing trouble for staff and customers. They had shown no unusual anger beforehand, two of them kept watch in what looked like a planned operation, and afterwards they told people at the shop, in effect, not to worry because he had been dealt with. The court accepted personal anger may have played some part, but not the dominant part.

That made the assault a grossly improper way of carrying out authorised work, rather than an act completely unconnected to it. The company was held vicariously liable. The trial judgment was set aside, the company was ordered to pay Mr Sprod’s costs of the trial and the appeal, and the case was sent back to the Supreme Court to assess his damages.

Why the assault was part of the job

The Court of Appeal looked at what the guards did before, during and after the assault to work out why they did it.

1

The guards were called in to do their job

Responding to the pizza shop's call for help was part of the guards' duties under the arrangement with the club. Removing Mr Sprod and stopping him from causing more trouble was work they were authorised to do.

2

Their behaviour pointed to duty, not personal revenge

For about 20 minutes before the assault the guards showed no unusual anger and didn't strike or threaten him. Two of them kept watch while the others acted, which suggested a planned step to deal with him rather than a spontaneous outburst.

3

What they said afterwards was telling

When the guards returned to the shop, they reassured people that he wouldn't cause any more trouble. The court read this as showing the assault was aimed at preventing further disturbance, which was connected to their role.

4

An improper way of doing authorised work

Weighing it all up, the court found the dominant reason for the assault was the guards' wish to carry out their duties. That made it a highly improper mode of doing their job, for which their employer is responsible.

Alex's Take
“

Most people assume that if someone commits a crime against them, the only person they can pursue is the person who did it. That’s often not the whole picture. When the attacker was working at the time, their employer may be responsible too, and an employer usually has insurance where an individual wrongdoer often has nothing.

This case also shows how fine the line is. The trial judge looked at the same facts and found the guards were on a frolic of their own. The appeal court found they were doing their job in a very wrong way. What tipped it was evidence about what the guards said and did before and after the assault. Witnesses mattered.

If you’ve been hurt by security staff, a bouncer or any other worker, don’t assume the door is closed because what they did was unlawful. Write down who was there and what was said, and get advice about who was employing them at the time.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →