A butcher at a Gold Coast meat processing plant worked back to back with a co-worker who had a violent past. Tension between them built for weeks, and both men told their supervisor. Nobody separated them, and the co-worker attacked him. Here's what happened and why it matters.
Employers aren't automatically liable when one worker assaults another. But when the warning signs pile up and a simple step like moving someone to another station would prevent it, failing to act can be a breach of duty.
Mr Colwell started work as a knife hand at Top Cut Foods’ meat processing plant at Burleigh Heads in October 2013. He worked back to back with a co-worker, about two metres apart, with their supervisor working right behind him. The co-worker had served time in prison overseas for serious violent offences, and had talked about his past at work.
Before Christmas 2013, Mr Colwell told the supervisor he was worried about the co-worker’s aggression. In mid-January 2014, the co-worker himself told the supervisor he was close to losing it and asked to be moved away from Mr Colwell. Days later there was a heated exchange between the two men.
On 20 January 2014, after another confrontation, the supervisor sent both men to the office together. On the way, the co-worker attacked Mr Colwell, punching him repeatedly in the head and face until two colleagues pulled him away. Mr Colwell suffered physical injuries and post-traumatic stress disorder. The co-worker was dismissed and later convicted.
Read the full judgment on Queensland CourtsThe District Court found in Mr Colwell’s favour. The co-worker had never been violent at that workplace, but the court found the supervisor knew, or should have known, of his history of violence. Combined with Mr Colwell’s complaint, the co-worker’s own request to be moved, and the escalating exchanges, the warnings were enough to put the employer on notice of the risk. The supervisor had also been given no training in managing staff or de-escalating conflict.
The court found the employer breached its duty by failing to act on the warnings and separate the two men, which could have been done at minimal cost. Sending them to the office together on the day, rather than separating them, was a further breach. The court rejected the argument that separation wouldn’t have helped because the men would still meet at breaks, finding it would likely have prevented the attack. Mr Colwell was awarded $609,362.09, reduced to $584,995.09 after repaying WorkCover.
The employer argued the attack came out of nowhere. The court looked at the weeks leading up to it and found the risk had been building in plain sight.
The co-worker had talked openly at work about his time in prison for violence. The court found the supervisor knew, or ought to have known, about it, even though the employer's witnesses said he had never been a problem at work.
Mr Colwell raised concerns about the co-worker's aggression before Christmas. Weeks later, the co-worker asked to be moved away from Mr Colwell, saying he was close to losing it. Neither request led to any change.
The court refused to treat the attack as an isolated first incident. Taken together, the complaints and the escalating exchanges put the employer on notice of the risk of violence.
Moving either worker to another station was feasible at minimal cost. On the day, the supervisor should have separated them instead of sending them off together. The court found these steps would likely have prevented the assault.
These are the core principles Queensland courts apply when a worker is injured by a co-worker's violence.
An employer's duty to provide a safe system of work can extend to protecting workers from violence by co-workers, where the risk is foreseeable and reasonable steps could reduce it.
Under section 305B of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), an employer only breaches its duty if it failed to take reasonable precautions against a risk it knew or ought to have known about. A worker simply feeling uneasy isn't always enough; the evidence must show the employer was on notice.
Courts weigh how likely and serious the harm could be against how difficult and expensive it would have been to prevent. Where a precaution is cheap and easy, failing to take it is harder to justify.
The worker must prove the injury probably wouldn't have happened if the employer had acted. Here, the court accepted that separating the men would likely have prevented the attack.
One of the most common things I hear from injured workers is “I told them, and nothing happened.” This case shows why that matters. No single warning here proved the attack was coming. But the court looked at them together, and together they were enough.
The fix was simple and cheap: move one of them to another station. When an employer has an easy, low-cost way to reduce a known risk and doesn’t use it, that weighs heavily against them.
If you’re worried about a co-worker’s behaviour, raise it, and do it in a way that leaves a record, like an email or a text to your supervisor. If you are hurt, that record can be the difference between an employer saying “we had no idea” and a court finding they were on notice.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.