Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

$650,000 for a Slip on Wet, Unlit Steps

Silwood v Chandler [2016] QCA 273

A new mother arrived at her former partner's house after dark to drop off their baby. He had hosed the front entry that afternoon and never dried it, and the outside light was off. She slipped on the steps and put her arm through a glass door. Here's what happened and why it matters.

Homeowners aren't expected to make their property risk-free. But if you create a hazard yourself, and your visitor has no way of seeing it, the law expects you to deal with it or at least warn them.

$650,000
Damages agreed by the parties if liability was proven
0%
Reduction for contributory negligence
3
Simple precautions the owner could have taken: dry, warn or light
The Case

Silwood v Chandler [2016] QCA 273

On the evening of 9 September 2008, Ms Chandler was exhausted from caring for the two-week-old baby she shared with her former partner, Mr Silwood. They agreed she would bring the baby to his house so she could get some rest. She arrived at about 8.30pm. It was dark, and the outside light near the front door wasn’t on.

Earlier that afternoon, Mr Silwood had noticed bat droppings on the wall beside his front door and hosed the area. He didn’t dry the tiled entry or the two tiled steps leading up to the door, and he didn’t mention it when they spoke on the phone before she came over.

As Ms Chandler stepped up towards the door, she slipped. Her outstretched arms went through the glass panel at the bottom of the door, and she suffered a serious injury to her right arm, including a damaged artery that needed urgent surgery.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

At trial in the Supreme Court, Chief Justice Holmes found the steps still held enough moisture to be slippery. A safety engineer’s slip resistance testing showed a wet surface posed a moderate to high risk of slipping, and the darkness meant Ms Chandler had no real chance of noticing it. Mr Silwood had also said after the fall that the steps might still have been wet, which showed he was conscious of the possibility. The court rejected the argument that Ms Chandler’s drinking earlier that evening contributed to her fall. The parties had agreed damages of $650,000 if liability was proven, and judgment was entered for that amount.

Mr Silwood appealed. He argued the water didn’t cause the fall, that Ms Chandler had approached the steps in an unexpected way, and that the trial judge had judged him with hindsight. On 28 October 2016 the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding the trial judge’s conclusions were thoroughly explained and well supported by the evidence. Given the steps were wet, slippery and dark, a fall was unsurprising, and a reasonable occupier would have dried them, warned her, or at least turned on the light.

Why the homeowner was found responsible

The homeowner argued the steps weren't wet, that the risk wasn't foreseeable, and that the visitor caused her own fall. The courts rejected each argument.

1

The steps were still wet

Although the hosing happened hours earlier, the court accepted expert evidence that residual moisture remained on the tiled steps. Slip testing showed that, when wet, the tiles carried a moderate to high slip risk.

2

The risk was foreseeable

The homeowner had owned the house for years without anyone falling on those steps, but that didn't mean the risk wasn't there. His own remark after the incident, that the steps might still have been wet, showed the possibility was on his mind.

3

Darkness made it worse

The outside light was off and the entry was dark. The court found the darkness took away any real chance Ms Chandler had of seeing that the steps were wet.

4

Her drinking didn't cause the fall

The defence argued Ms Chandler had been drinking and was careless. The court didn't accept that this contributed to the fall, so her damages weren't reduced.

Alex's Take
“

This isn’t a case about a homeowner being expected to wrap his house in cotton wool. The courts are clear that paths crack, leaves fall and surfaces get slippery, and that’s often just part of life. What made the difference here was that he created the hazard himself, hours earlier, and then left his visitor to walk into it in the dark.

Notice how simple the precautions were. Dry the steps. Mention they might be wet. Flick on the porch light. When a precaution costs almost nothing, courts are much more willing to find that a reasonable person would have taken it.

If you’ve been hurt on someone else’s property, don’t assume it’s your fault just because you were the one who fell. What the owner knew, and what they did or didn’t do about it, matters. Get advice early, while the evidence about the conditions is still available.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →