Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

$148,917 Awarded, Then Overturned on Appeal

Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd v Tat [2018] QCA 182

A shift worker at a Brisbane chicken processing plant was attacked by a former employee in the staff car park late at night. She won at trial. The Court of Appeal agreed her employer had breached its duty of care, but still overturned her win. Here's what happened and why it matters.

Proving your employer did the wrong thing is only half the case. You also have to prove, with evidence rather than guesswork, that doing the right thing would have prevented your injury.

$148,917
Awarded at trial, clear of the WorkCover refund
4
Links in the causation chain the court said weren't proven
$0
Recovered after the Court of Appeal overturned the win
The Case

Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd v Tat [2018] QCA 182

Ms Tat was a shift worker at Inghams’ chicken processing factory at Murarrie in Brisbane. Late on the night of 1 February 2013, after her shift, she was approached in the factory car park by a former Inghams employee. He spun her a false story about needing help, and when she tried to get into her car, he grabbed at her. She escaped and ran to co-workers for help, but developed significant post-traumatic stress disorder.

Earlier that night, the same man had approached three other female workers in or near the car park with similar stories. They found him strange and frightening, but none of them reported him to the security guard stationed at the gate.

Ms Tat sued Inghams under the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), arguing it had failed to protect workers from the risk of violence in the car park at night.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

At trial in the District Court, the judge found Inghams had breached its duty of care in two ways: it hadn’t trained staff to report suspicious behaviour in and around the car park, and its security measures weren’t geared to the risk of violence from outsiders. The judge concluded that, with proper training, one of the other women would have reported the man, security would have moved him on, and the attack wouldn’t have happened. Ms Tat was awarded $148,916.87, clear of her WorkCover refund.

The Court of Appeal agreed the risk was foreseeable and that Inghams had breached its duty. It also rejected Inghams’ argument that the trial judge had used hindsight or treated a warning email sent to staff after the attack as an admission of liability.

But on causation, the Court of Appeal found the trial judge’s reasons were inadequate and the evidence didn’t support the chain of events the finding depended on. Each step was conjecture rather than a reasonable inference. The appeal was allowed, judgment was entered for Inghams, and Ms Tat was ordered to pay Inghams’ costs.

Four assumptions the evidence couldn't carry

To win, the worker needed the court to accept a chain of events that would have stopped the attack. The Court of Appeal found every link in that chain was conjecture.

1

That another worker would have reported him

The trial judge assumed that, with proper training, at least one of the three women approached earlier would have reported the man to security. The Court of Appeal found the evidence about each woman's circumstances didn't support that conclusion. It was speculation.

2

That the security guard would have found him

Even if a report had been made, there was no evidence about how or when the guard would have located the man in the car park. The court called this conjecture.

3

That he would have left when asked

There was nothing to show the man would have complied with a direction from security to leave. A finding that he would have done so had no evidentiary basis.

4

That he wouldn't have come back

The man had already persisted despite other deterrents that night. The court found no secure basis for concluding he would have stayed away long enough for Ms Tat to reach her car safely.

Alex's Take
“

This is a hard case to read, because the worker did almost everything right. She proved the risk was foreseeable. She proved her employer fell short. And she still walked away with nothing, plus a costs order against her.

The lesson is about evidence. Courts won’t fill gaps with “what probably would have happened.” If your case depends on a chain of events, such as a co-worker reporting something, security acting on it, and the danger going away, each link needs evidence behind it. Witness statements, security procedures, response times, what the other person actually did. Without it, a strong breach case can fall over on causation.

That’s why it matters who prepares your claim and how early. The work that wins on causation is done long before trial, when the evidence is still there to collect.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened at work.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →