Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

Nearly $1 Million After Being Hit by a Car

Eden v Jamieson [2023] QSC 240

A Queensland court awarded a sparky almost $990,000 after he was struck from behind while walking on the side of the road. Here's what the court decided, and what it means for you.

Understanding how courts decide fault in road accident cases can help you know where you stand after an injury.

$987,655
Total damages awarded
0%
Contributory negligence found
80m
The visibility distance the court found decisive
The Case

Eden v Jamieson [2023] QSC 240

On the evening of 9 April 2020, the plaintiff was walking along the side of the Dysart Bypass Road towards a friend’s business when a car struck him from behind. It was dark and there was no street lighting. He had drunk two beers before setting out, although the court found he wasn’t affected by alcohol. He was carrying the rest of the beers in a white plastic bag and wearing a t-shirt with a large white design on the back. There were nature strips on either side of the road, but he was walking on the road itself.

The driver claimed he didn’t see the plaintiff until he was just 10 metres away, making it impossible to avoid the collision. He argued the plaintiff was negligent for walking on the road instead of the nature strip, for not keeping a lookout for cars, and for not stepping off the road as he approached.

The plaintiff sustained multiple injuries. The dominant injury was a fracture and dislocation of his left shoulder, requiring surgery. He was a licensed electrician who had just secured a job doing electrical work at a mine, but after the accident he was left unable to perform heavy mine work or above-shoulder work.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

The Supreme Court found that because the road was long and straight, the night was clear, and the white design on the plaintiff’s shirt and his white bag made him stand out, he would have been visible to the driver from about 80 metres away, even on low beam. The driver had plenty of time to see him and take action. Failing to do so was negligence.

On the question of whether the plaintiff was partly at fault for walking on the road, the court said no. The nature strips on either side were not safe to use: one was overgrown with long grass and the other dropped away into a steep drain. Walking on the road was a reasonable choice in the circumstances, and because he was hit from behind, he only heard the tyres screech when it was too late to get out of the way. The driver couldn’t prove the plaintiff had failed to take reasonable care for his own safety.

The damages were substantial because the accident effectively ended the plaintiff’s career in heavy mine electrical work. He could only perform light electrical work going forward, representing a significant loss of future earning capacity. The court assessed his damages at $987,654.99.

Three key findings from the court

The case turned on what the driver should have seen, whether the plaintiff should have walked somewhere else, and what the injuries cost him in future work.

1

The driver had a duty to keep a proper lookout

The court found the plaintiff was visible from about 80 metres away. Claiming he wasn't seen until 10 metres simply didn't stack up on a long, straight road on a clear night, and the court found the driver had only seen him at around 35 to 40 metres. A driver who fails to keep a proper lookout is liable for the consequences.

2

Walking on the road was not negligent

The nature strips were not safely usable. Walking on the road was a reasonable response to the available options, and the court rejected any finding of contributory negligence against the plaintiff.

3

Career-ending injuries attract large damages

Because the accident effectively ended the plaintiff's ability to do high-value mine work, the court awarded significant compensation for future loss of earning capacity, almost $600,000 of the total. These awards can be substantial when the injury changes a person's career trajectory.

Alex's Take
“

Drivers and their insurers often reach for contributory negligence the moment a pedestrian was on the road rather than a footpath, or had a drink earlier in the evening. This case shows a court won’t accept that argument just because it’s made. The insurer has to prove it, and here the evidence about the nature strips, the plaintiff’s visibility and the angle of impact all pointed the other way.

The other lesson is about damages. The plaintiff’s physical injuries didn’t come with high impairment ratings, but the court looked at the work he could no longer do. Losing a well-paid mining job and being limited to light electrical work is what took this award close to a million dollars.

If you’ve been hit while walking, take photos of the scene as soon as you can, including the verges and footpaths, and keep records of the work you were doing or about to start. That evidence can be hard to rebuild later, and it can make a real difference to how fault and damages are decided.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →