Start a Claim Login
Matters in the Media

$237,770 for a Bullying Complaint Ignored

Keegan v Sussan Corporation (Aust.) Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 64

An experienced assistant store manager came back from maternity leave to a new manager who criticised, excluded and belittled her. When she rang her employer's business manager in tears, the complaint went nowhere. The Supreme Court held the employer responsible for her psychiatric injury. Here's what happened and why it matters.

An employer isn't expected to read minds. But once you tell them you're being bullied and you're not coping, they must take reasonable steps, and their own bullying policy is a good guide to what those steps are.

11
Days she worked after returning from leave
$303,901
Damages assessed before the WorkCover refund
$237,770
Final judgment for Ms Keegan
The Case

Keegan v Sussan Corporation (Aust.) Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 64

Ms Keegan had worked at Sussan’s Cairns Central store since 2004 and was a capable, well-regarded assistant store manager. While she was on maternity leave in 2010, the store manager left and Sussan hired a new manager with no fashion retail experience.

Ms Keegan returned to work on 7 September 2010. Over the next 11 working days, the new manager criticised her, left her out of things she needed to know to do her job, spoke to her aggressively and, on one occasion, held a mop close to her face.

On her fourth day she rang Sussan’s Queensland business manager in tears and said she was being bullied. Instead of following Sussan’s bullying and harassment policy, the business manager suggested she “put some lippy on” and spoke to the store manager herself. Ms Keegan called again as things continued, and was eventually told she would have to work it out with the manager herself. She stopped work, never returned, and was diagnosed with a psychiatric injury involving depression and anxiety.

Read the full judgment on Queensland Courts

What the Court Decided

Justice Henry of the Supreme Court, sitting in Cairns, largely preferred Ms Keegan’s account of what happened over those 11 days. He described her phone call on day four as the pivot point of the case. Before it, Sussan had no reason to expect she might be injured. Only the day before, she had told the business manager everything was fine.

After the call, things were different. A reasonable employer would have realised that if the complaint wasn’t properly dealt with, the bullying would likely continue and Ms Keegan would be left more isolated and distressed. Sussan’s own policy said complaints would be dealt with seriously. Instead, the complaint wasn’t investigated or handled confidentially, and she was effectively left to resolve it with the person she was complaining about. That was a breach of Sussan’s duty of care.

The court found that breach caused her injury. Her personality made her more vulnerable but didn’t break the link. Damages were assessed at $303,901.36. After deducting the $66,131.57 WorkCover refund, judgment was entered for Ms Keegan for $237,770.

Why the employer was held responsible

The court didn't find Sussan liable simply because a manager behaved badly. It focused on what Sussan knew, when it knew it, and what it did next.

1

The behaviour went beyond normal supervision

An assistant manager can expect correction and direction. But the court found the new manager's conduct, taken together, was unreasonable and excessive enough to signal a real risk of emotional harm.

2

Her phone call on day four was the turning point

Until Ms Keegan called in tears and said she was being bullied, Sussan had no reason to foresee injury. After that call, a psychiatric injury was reasonably foreseeable if the complaint wasn't properly handled.

3

Sussan didn't follow its own bullying policy

The policy promised complaints would be dealt with seriously. Instead, there was no investigation, no confidential handling and no real support. Ms Keegan was left to resolve it with the manager herself.

4

The poor response helped cause the injury

The court accepted that the lack of support from the business manager was itself a contributing cause. Ms Keegan's personality made her more vulnerable, but that didn't stop Sussan being liable.

Alex's Take
“

What stands out in this case is that the bullying itself lasted less than three weeks. What turned it into a successful claim was the employer’s response. Ms Keegan told the business that she was being bullied, she was upset, and she asked for help. From that moment, the business was on notice.

Workplace policies matter here. Most employers have a bullying policy that promises complaints will be taken seriously. When an employer ignores its own policy, a court can use that as a measure of what reasonable care looked like. Telling someone to sort it out themselves is not a reasonable response.

If you’re being bullied, tell someone in authority, in writing if you can, and say plainly how it’s affecting you. Keep a record of what happens next. If you’ve already been injured, get advice before you resign or sign anything, because the timing and content of your complaints can make a real difference.

Alex Bassingthwaighte
Alex Bassingthwaighte
Founder & Principal, Claimwise
Ready when you are

Tell us what happened at work.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.

Make an Enquiry

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get Free Advice →