A university security officer was yelled at and wrongly accused by a senior manager during a campus power outage. The university already knew he had done something similar to another staff member and had barely responded. She lost at trial on causation, then won on appeal. Here's what happened and why it matters.
When an employer knows a manager has a pattern of aggressive behaviour and does little about it, the law can hold the employer responsible for what happens next, provided you can show that proper action would probably have made a difference.
Ms Wolters was a well-regarded security officer at the University of the Sunshine Coast. On the morning of 14 March 2008, a power outage hit the campus and a fire alarm went off in the sports stadium. Ms Wolters was in charge of the security radio and phone, and she took a call about the alarm while in a colleague’s office.
A senior manager, Mr Bradley, first criticised her loudly over the radio. He then confronted her in a breezeway, waving his arms, yelling and accusing her of abandoning her duties. The accusations were unjustified. Ms Wolters developed an adjustment disorder.
Three months earlier, Mr Bradley had yelled at and threatened another female staff member, who made a formal complaint, suffered a psychiatric injury and left the university. The university didn’t investigate that complaint. The Vice-Chancellor only had an informal chat with Mr Bradley, relying on his side of the story.
Read the full judgment on Queensland CourtsAt trial in the Supreme Court, Justice Applegarth found the university owed Ms Wolters a duty to take reasonable care to avoid psychiatric injury, and that it breached that duty by failing to investigate the earlier complaint and to properly reprimand and counsel Mr Bradley. But he wasn’t persuaded that counselling would have stopped the incident. Mr Bradley thought he was dealing with a crisis, and his reaction was impulsive. The negligence claim was dismissed, and Ms Wolters received only $100 in nominal damages for breach of her employment contract.
The Court of Appeal disagreed. It said the trial judge had not worked out what the counselling should actually have contained. A proper investigation would have shown Mr Bradley’s problem was attacking staff before checking the facts. Appropriate counselling would therefore have told him to check his facts before criticising anyone, and to deliver any criticism calmly and courteously.
Given that, the Court of Appeal found it more likely than not that he would have checked with Ms Wolters first, and the incident would not have happened. The power outage didn’t change that. The appeal was allowed, the trial orders were set aside, and the university was ordered to pay damages of $364,008.06.
Both courts agreed the university fell short. The difference was in how they tested whether doing the right thing would have prevented the incident.
Three months before, the same manager had yelled at and threatened another female employee. She complained formally and was later accepted by WorkCover for a psychiatric injury. That put the university on notice.
The university never investigated the earlier complaint. The Vice-Chancellor spoke informally to Mr Bradley, relying on his account alone. Both courts found this was a breach of the university's duty.
Justice Applegarth thought Mr Bradley's reaction during the power outage was impulsive and probably would have happened anyway, so causation wasn't proved.
Properly targeted counselling would have told him to check the facts first and to criticise staff calmly and courteously. More likely than not, he would then have checked with Ms Wolters before reacting.
These are the core principles Queensland courts apply when a worker claims psychiatric injury caused by a manager's conduct.
Once an employer knows a manager is aggressive and capable of causing psychiatric harm to staff, it owes a duty to take reasonable steps to stop that harm happening to others.
Under the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), the worker must prove the employer's failure was a necessary condition of the injury. The worker carries that burden.
Where the claim is that an employer failed to do something, the court must work out precisely what proper action would have involved, then ask whether that action would probably have avoided the harm.
A general warning is not the same as targeted counselling. Courts can look at what a proper investigation would have revealed, and what a manager should have been told as a result.
I see this pattern often. Someone senior has an outburst, a complaint is made, and the organisation has a quiet word and moves on. Then it happens again, to someone else. This case says that when an employer knows about that kind of behaviour, a quiet word may not be enough.
The lesson from the appeal is about detail. It wasn’t enough to say the manager should have been counselled. The court looked at what that counselling should have said, and whether those specific messages would probably have changed his behaviour on the day. That is the kind of analysis that wins or loses a psychiatric injury claim.
If you’ve been treated like this at work, write down what happened, find out whether others have complained about the same person, and keep copies of any complaint you make. Get advice early, because evidence about what your employer knew is often what decides these cases.

One conversation. No pressure. Tell us a bit about your situation and we'll be in touch.